Mainstream media fails on accurate ‘Don’t Ask’ repeal reporting


I’ve noticed a lot of mainstream news reports covering the DADT hearings int he Senate Armed Services Committee this week have run headlines like this morning’s McClatchy report: “Generals: Don’t rescind military gay ban.” The intro on the story: “Highest-ranking leaders urge Congress to keep ‘don’t ask, don’t tell.'”

But, what McClatchy is reporting isn’t exactly true.

Washington Blade has a better, more balanced and nuanced story. I reported on the DADT hearings as well at Campus Progress. From what I’ve watched myself and read elsewhere, the arguments put forward by military leaders don’t match up to McClatchy’s version of the hearings.

Military leaders (with the exception of Marine Corps Commandent John Amos, aren’t saying “don’t end DADT.” It’s more like: “We know DADT repeal is inevitable, and we can implement it faithfully, but don’t rush through it because we need time to make it work.” Even Amos has pledged to “faithfully implement” a repeal when (not if) it happens, and each branch chief, including the Coast Guard, has said they trust the leadership of Pentagon and Defense Department leaders to know when the armed forces are really ready.

That’s an entirely different kind of argument than “Don’t rescind military gay ban.”

A big, fat mainstream media #FAIL.

Photo: Navy Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates, Department of Defense General Counsel Jeh C. Johnson and U.S. Army Gen. Carter Ham, commander, U.S. Army, Europe appear before the Senate Armed Services Committee regarding the findings of the “Dont Ask, Dont Tell” Comprehensive Working Group report on Dec. 2, 2010. (DoD photo by Mass Communication Specialist 1st Class Chad J. McNeeley/Released, via Flickr).


Comments
2 Responses to “Mainstream media fails on accurate ‘Don’t Ask’ repeal reporting”
  1. Juan Claudio says:

    Ironically, I work in the Pentagon. Many people knew me when I served in uniform. A few even knew I was gay. When the others put 2+2 together, since they now see me in a coat and tie suit, the anti-gay jokes stopped. I was the same person before, during, and after service in the military. Yes, we still have people in the military who were raised to have strong bias’ against gay people, but we also have a younger generation raised without that bias. Look at the ages of the senior military leaders and you’ll see my point. You can also tell which ones are progressive and those who are not. This BS about military readiness is the wrong response to why DAT should not be repealed. It has more to do with personal bias against gays.

  2. AndrewW says:

    Of course it’s all just a charade and Gay Inc. is on the scheme. This is just supposed to look like “we were so close,” followed by fundraising requests from Democrats and the LGBT-advocacy industry.

    The votes aren’t there (60 in the US Senate) for DADT repeal, no matter how much anyone wants to pretend.

    STOP FUNDING PHONY LGBT ADVOCACY AND ACTIVIST ORGANIZATIONS UNTIL THEY HAVE A STRATEGY TO WIN.

Leave A Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.